There’s no time to passively wait on this issue, folks. Seniors are heavily in favor of tax on legal services, as it will replace property tax, and make it more affordable to hold onto their homes when limited to social security. Pennsylvania Realtors (“PAR”) are also heavily pushing this tax “reform” because the real estate tax is a factor which can impact a buyer’s decision for one residence or another. They have a well-funded PAC, and it’s alleged that among the various groups which have put this bill forward, there is $1,000,000 or more in financing pushing it forward.
On the other hand, the Pennsylvania Bar PAC has about $250,000. Outnumbered in voices, and crushed by the funding disparity, it’s not looking good right now. The sales tax in PA will increase from 6% to 7% under SB 76. Sales tax on legal services would be 7%.
Tax guru Kelly Phillips Erb, Esquire, makes another point:
To be clear, it’s not just sales taxes that would increase in the Commonwealth. Personal INCOME taxes in the Commonwealth will also increase in order to offset the loss in property tax revenue (likely landing somewhere around 4.25% eventually – a rate that is higher than the rate of personal income growth). That boost, together with the increase in sales tax base, will not be enough to offset the difference as initially determined by the Independent Fiscal Office. The IFO – which looks at data but does not support or oppose a position – did a rather thorough analysis of the proposal
Let your voice be heard. Contact your Senator and express your opposition to Senate Bill 76. PBA can’t do it alone. Not only will this tax have a chilling effect on access to legal services for those of marginal income, but it will be an administrative nightmare for law firms, particularly solo and small firms.
Imagine if you have to pay sales tax when billed, but you don’t actually collect it (or your fees) for months. Does your billing software even have the capability to charge tax? Most do not. That’s because there are only 3 states in the nation which tax legal services: Hawaii, New Mexico and South Dakota – which takes the form of a gross receipts tax in each state. Apparently FLA had a tax on legal services, but repealed it due to problems in administration. Read the ABA statement.